oil

Viewing 10 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #36189
      Bob Rooks
      Participant
        • Offline

        Account deleted.

      • #36190
        DavidPrivett
        Participant
          • Offline

          well what I ment was the differences  in the additives between 15/40 ch and 10/30 sj . off the top someones head,no big deal.

        • #36191
          RichWaugh
          Participant
            • Offline

            15W40 is a diesel-rated oil and has additives to keep the soot (carbon) in suspension.  10W30 is an automotive oil and is probably a detergent type with no soot suspension additive.  If this is a diesel, definitely use the 15W40.

          • #36192
            Bob Rooks
            Participant
              • Offline

              Rich is correct.

              Here is an example (I picked Chevron because it was convenient, and I use it. roflmao)

              As you can see from the example, 15w/40 is a superior lubricant over the 10w/30, and this will be pretty much the norm across the market spectrum. The “LE” designation is intended for use in post 2007 engines.

              (I was surprised to see the Delo 710 lubricant listed as this is an oil specially formulated for use in our 4,000 HP EMD 710G engines).

              Account deleted.

            • #36193
              DavidPrivett
              Participant
                • Offline

                ok with that in mind why did the chinese tag a 3 hp gas engine with 15/40 oil requirements on that genrerator and other manfs do not require it? I am puzzled.I am sure 15/40 is a better oil with that in mind why do these other manfs. do not put that in the instruction as what to use? is it to good?extends the life maybe to much?am I getting to deep?

              • #36194
                RichWaugh
                Participant
                  • Offline

                  If that's really a 3hp gas engine, then I'd use 10W40 or straight 30wt.  I'd guess that they specc'ed 15W-40 because they don't really understand that in our US nomenclature that s a diesel-rated oil and the gas equivalent is 10W-40.  YOu don't need the soot suspension additive in a gas engine, but the detergent isn't a bad idea, so I'd use a gas engine oil.  In my climate, where it never gets really cold, I generally use straight weight oils.  Straight 30wt for all my small gas engines – until they get so sloppy they need heavier oil to keep from fouling plugs.  roflmao

                • #36195
                  Bob Rooks
                  Participant
                    • Offline

                    You can use any of those oils and you will be fine, but I'd prefer the 20w/40. The 10w/30 may be easier to crank in cold climates.

                    3 HP equates to only 2.2 kW, and that's not figuring any losses.

                    Account deleted.

                  • #36196
                    Dan Lewis
                    Participant
                      • Offline

                      One reason a person might want to run a 15-40  diesel engine oil in a gas engine  that is a standard ohv with standard (non roller lifters) or cam -solid lifter including hydraulic solid lifter, is reduced wear on the cam/ lifter  wear interface…

                       

                        Since the oil companies  (by order of the EPA) have been reducing the  ZDDP (Zinc Dialkyl Dithio Phosphate) -contains Zinc and  Phosphorous materials that are sacrificed -instead of the metal of the cam and lifters  due to metal to metal contact- resulting in premature wear.

                       

                      All diesel rated oils have more of these sacrificial metals  which can save wear of the solid lifters and cam.. Some people buy the  ZDDP additives  and add them to for high $ 60's muscle cars. Personally I run Shell Rotella T in my 69 GTO engine and  some other older American gas engines…  my 2 cents

                    • #36197
                      DavidPrivett
                      Participant
                        • Offline

                        well the overhead valve wear thing is a good thought since straight 30 wt oil is getting a little harder to find by the gal. maybe 15/40 will get put in the ohv's that I have afterall lawnmowers operate in very dusty conditions some extra antiwear propertys can not hurt.

                      • #36208
                        Carl Darnell
                        Participant
                          • Offline

                          I run Rotella T 15w40 in everything I own and have done so since the 1970's when Cummins Engine Company had serious issues with Chevron Delo 400. I consider the extra protection the Rotella T provides worth using it over anything else on the market.

                        • #36212
                          DavidPrivett
                          Participant
                            • Offline

                            yea that is the road I am going to go down ,I am just going to use up what is here, then one  engine oil 15/40.

                        Viewing 10 reply threads
                        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.