Are you sure it’s the “battery light” and not the “key on” indicator light? There is also a red LED on the voltage regulator that indicates there is “sense” voltage to the alternator field circuit.
Also, if you upgrade to a Delco Si series alternator you will have to upgrade the wiring because the OEM alternator only has a nominal output of around 14 amps. And it is recommended to install a smaller pulley to allow the Delco to perform as required.